Wednesday, May 23, 2018
Planners are No Long Generalists with a Specialty
There’s recent discussion in urban planning journals about the way professional city planners should be educated today. Almost fifty years ago, Professor Harvey Perloff at UCLA suggested that the way to think about educating urban planners was in terms of training “generalists with a specialty.” He thought all planners should have basic professional skills and theoretical knowledge coupled with more detailed techniques and understandings related to an area of application or specialization, like housing or urban design. When Perloff (who I knew) was thinking about it, the general or shared portion of the curriculum probably equaled about 8 – 10 of the 14 semester long courses students were expected to complete in a two-year curriculum (plus a master’s thesis). So general knowledge constituted 70% of the degree. The general portion of the curriculum has continued to shrink over the past 50 years. Now it is probably no more than 25% - 30% of the curriculum, and students can choose multiple ways of covering some general requirements by taking different versions of methods or applied social science courses offered in other departments (or by-passing test-out exams). This allows them to satisfy their differing interests.
So, my estimate is that 70% of the curriculum is now keyed to specialized knowledge and skills while the shared portion of the curriculum today represents only 30% of the credits students are required to complete. While this sometimes makes it difficult for students in the same cohort to understand why they are getting the same degree (since they are mostly studying such different things), it reflects the dramatic explosion of knowledge in adjacent fields that planning specialists know they need to master. I’ve taught at MIT in the Department of Urban Studies and Planning (DUSP) for almost fifty years. Since the early 1980’s I’ve had responsibility for building DUSP’s Environmental Policy and Planning (EPP) specialization. Let me offer a quick description of how both the generalized knowledge that planning students are expected to master has changed, even as it has shrunk, and how the specialized knowledge in the environmental planning specialization (and I think it is similar to other specialties like housing, community development, transportation and regional economic development) has evolved as well.
Most of today’s city planners are not preparing for life-long careers in municipal planning departments or city planning consulting firms the way their predecessors were. Instead, they are as likely to go to work in the private sector (as a sustainability officer for a major corporation), the public sector (as staff to an elected official) or in the non-for-profit sector (heading an NGO). And, even if they are aiming for a public sector job, it is very possible they will be working at the metropolitan, state, or national rather than the neighborhood or municipal level. They might spend part of their time working in the US, but they are almost as likely to spend a portion of their career working in another part of the world (where the growth of cities, especially mega-cities, is relentless). Indeed, a very large portion of the graduate students currently studying in the 60+ urban planning schools in America are from other parts of the world, and likely to return home. City planners are no longer restricted to gathering the information needed to turn out master plans or sector plans (like transportation investment schemes). They are more likely to be involved in formulating climate adaptation strategies, promoting new downtown arts districts or working to protect critical urban infrastructure from cyberattack. Moreover, their roles and responsibilities will shift many times during their careers as they morph from a design role, to a policy analyst’s role, to an advocacy or community organizing role, to a mediating role, or even a futurist’s role.
The kinds of practitioners that agencies and organizations want to hire must be multi-talented, tech savvy, committed to taking action in the world, capable negotiators and able to write and speak effectively in contentious public settings. To survive in these situations, planning graduates must be clear about their ethical obligations and continuously reflective, adapting their personal theories of practice as they encounter and learn from each new situation.
The New General Curriculum
While the list of required subjects in today’s urban planning departments may look somewhat similar to the class titles of two or three decades ago, I can assure you that the content, and in many schools the pedagogy, are quite different. Today’s course about the planning profession and the basics of planning practice address a which wider range of themes than the old version of those courses. And, the ethical dilemmas (i.e. How can we promote economic growth while maintaining the most important cultural elements of long-standing communities? How can we ensure more efficient transportation and energy production while moving people to healthier lifestyles and a fairer allocation of public resources?) are front and center. The need for collaboration in all kinds of decision-making is highlighted (linked to much less reliance on expert decision-making). This demands a new repertoire of skills and techniques; incorporating knowledge from the social sciences and the natural sciences,but requiring a meta-analysis of whose knowledge this is and how it ought to be shared. The challenges and opportunities posed by social media pose choices that planners never had to make; now they have to learn how to make sure that scientific and technical input are not pushed to the side in the face of efforts to empower more people to participate or buried beneath the partisan debates that dominate our political world. MIT requires every student to take classes in the history of the planning profession, methods of economic analysis; and tools of data management, data mapping and statistical analysis, but it is increasingly difficult to argue that there is only one way of presenting this material. Students can learn the basics of microeconomic analysis by focusing on land market, housing prices, natural resource management, or energy policy, in the United States or in any other country. They need to learn research methods to write a thesis, but these methods might diverge depending on whether they are going to study the way mangrove forests were being managed in Malaysia or the effectiveness of a particular community development strategy in Detroit. So, not only does the content of the general portion of the curriculum keep changing, but the best way of learning that content might depend on the substantive or specialized interest of each student.
This brings me to the changing nature and expansion of the specialized portions of urban planning degree programs in the United States.
The Evolving Specialized Curriculum
The Environmental Policy and Planning specialization at MIT allows students to focus on transboundary water management, renewable energy and energy efficiency, environmental justice, forest management, food systems, post-disaster relief and reconstruction, coastal zone management, ecosystem services, climate change (mitigation and adaptation), healthy communities, mass transit systems, and monitoring efforts aimed at promoting sustainability and resilience. With a relatively small full-time EPP faculty of five or six (some of whom are shared with other specializations), we have to depend on the availability of coursework in the other two dozen departments at MIT and through cross-registration at Harvard. We expect students to take only half of their course work each semester in our department. We insist that they have a primary thesis advisor from DUSP, but we encourage them to add a reader or additional advisor from another department or from the world of practice. Almost all students are working 10 -15 hours throughout the two years on a research or community-based project as a way of financing their tuition. They look for projects that allow them to apply what they are learning in class. In addition to a thesis we require students to take a Practicum – a semester-long problem-focused course with a client. (In the old days these were called Studios and they usually resulted in a design of some sort. Now they are as likely to produce policy advice to the mayor of Mexico City on ways of improving the efficiency and fairness of mass transit operations in that city. Note though, that most Practicums are offered through a specialization.)
In EPP we offer four or five sets of two or three subjects dealing with different natural resource management or environmental problems (i.e., climate change, water management, energy systems, healthy communities, environmental justice). These are enough to prepare our students so they can participate in classes at the Harvard School of Public Health, MIT’s Department of Earth, Atmosphere and Planetary Sciences, the Sloan School of Management, the Department of Chemical Engineering, or work at one of the many interdisciplinary labs or research projects around the campus. If there is a gap in what’s covered around the campus, we will add a temporary instructor in a field like plant ecology or energy efficiency.
Almost all of the DUSP faculty teach comparatively. We have to, since a significant share of our graduate students are not American. While I don’t think there is a “one world” approach to teaching planning that applies equally well everywhere, I do think that an explicitly comparative approach to teaching environmental planning will prepare students (as long as they also develop cross-cultural communication skills and a sense of cross-cultural awareness) to work outside their home country. Also, within their specialties they are learning how the same challenges are being dealt with differently in different countries.
Each of the four main specializations in DUSP (i.e., EPP, Housing and Community Economic Development, City Design and Development and International Development) offers an introductory graduate course. Mine is the Introduction to Environmental Policy and Planning. You can see the curriculum at MIT Open CourseWare (ocw.mit.edu). You can also read all the materials students are assigned, see the exams and the best student responses, and even videos the best short oral presentations in responses to simulated practice scenarios. These are included in our E-book called Environmental Problem-Solvingpublished by Anthem Press and written with two of my doctoral students and a faculty colleague (Bruno Verdini, Jessica Gordon, and Yasmin Zaerpoor). The four segments of the course deal with the dynamics of environmental policy-making, environmental ethics, methods of environmental analysis and forecasting and collaborative problem-solving. Segments from all the assigned readings are included in the book with permission. While this is an introduction to one of the specializations
in the Department, it covers a version of some of the general problems and themes that all planners need to know about. It illustrates how material that was once covered in a unified fashion in the general curriculum (that all students had to take) is now covered in an expanding specialization so that students can learn about general planning practice requirements while establishing their identity as a specialist in environmental planning. (MIT even offers a Certificate in Environmental Planning so that students who receive a general MCP degree can convince potential employers that they really are environmental specialists.)
We are still trying to figure out how to support additional specializations (i.e. urban science, smart cities, and cybersecurity; arts, new media and technology-assisted communication; and neuroscience, behavioral economics, entrepreneurship and social innovation). We are also continuing to experiment with new pedagogical forms (i.e. blended courses that combine elaborately designed online elements with face-to-face elements; role play simulations, and real-time video feedback on practice simulations).
Conclusion
It is no longer relevant to think of planning education as training generalists with a specialty; rather, we are now training specialists with heightened applied social science, action science and reflective practice capabilities who are ready to work anywhere in the world. And, while faculty are still judged (in terms of promotion) on the theoretical/research they publish, they are required to teach analytical methods, applied social science, and planning history in ways that heighten the usefulness of theory for practice. In addition, our faculty includes Professors of Practice and Lecturers who complement the members of our tenured faculty who come out of traditional disciplinary fields. There is no conflict in our Department between theory and practice.
Posted by Lawrence Susskind at 8:00 AM 0 comments
Labels: DUSP, Environmental Planning specialization, generalist with a specialty, MIT, urban planning education
Tuesday, December 26, 2017
Three Surprising Leadership Skills
MIT is looking ahead, trying to figure out what skills the
next generation of scientists, engineers, applied social scientists, designers
and managers will need. After careful consideration,
and a close review of numerous studies of the future of work, MIT believes it
will have to complement the depth of the training it currently offers in dozens
of technical fields with an equal commitment to developing the breadth of each
individual’s leadership capabilities. To build this necessary breadth, it will
be necessary to focus on helping learners know
themselves (e.g., improve their emotional intelligence, adaptability,
resilience, ethnical awareness, reflective capacity, etc.), work with others to get things done
(e.g. motivate others, give and receive feedback, build teams and networks,
communicate effectively, resolve conflict, and negotiate with difficult people);
and build organizational capacity
(e.g., manage change, manage crises, help organizations learn, implement user
experience design and better marketing, and commit to process improvement). No one can learn all these things at once; so,
we’ll all have to commit to life-long self-improvement. The university’s job
will be to make it easy for everyone to acquire both technical depth and leadership
breadth as they need it. In all
likelihood, this will involve a range of new teaching and learning formats.
As I listen to successful individuals say what it took for
them to achieve their goals (at every level, in every sector), many seem to be
stuck on an old-fashioned view of a leader as someone with a strong personal vision
who can command others to do what needs to be done. In my view, this model -- derived mostly from
accounts of military, sports, political and business victories -- is not likely
to work in the future. More distributed or facilitative models of leadership-- that
emphasize knowing how to work in partnership with others and build organizational
capacity -- are likely to be more valuable. When I look at the way ideas about leadership
are changing at MIT, shifting from top-down to facilitative models, three specific
leadership skills stand out for me: setting a constructive problem-solving
tone, facilitating group efforts and negotiating in a value-creating fashion. These
are likely to surprise traditionalists, but I think we can already see how these
capabilities will define a new generation of leaders.
Setting a
constructive problem-solving tone
What do leaders need to be aware of at the outset of a
venture? Not just their own goals and
vision, but the way their behavior influences others. Efforts to establish one’s
firmness or strength are less important than an ability to model or set a joint
problem-solving tone. Whatever the organizational context, technical managers,
team leaders and CEOs must be able to motivate and inspire others to work and
think creatively. The more everyone is ready to share responsibility for the
success of the group, the lighter each person’s load will be, and the greater
the collective wisdom available to apply to problem-solving. Leaders
are people who are able to put themselves in the shoes of others. They are in sufficient control of their ego to
be able to share responsibility and applaud the good work of others. Emotional intelligence
and self-awareness are crucial to the ongoing success of teams or organizations
in an era of flattened hierarchies and distributed leadership. If a leader can’t
inspire a problem-solving tone, commanding that everyone perform is likely to
backfire.
Facilitating group
efforts
The general presumption in the world of management is that
technical experts will be able to collaborate with each other; it turns out,
though, that collaboration is a learned, not an innate capability. Launching multifaceted
high-performance teams is an important leadership responsibility, and it
involves being able to facilitate group interactions, not just leaving
everything to the team members. In my
view, facilitation is a crucial leadership skill. Those of us who teach
facilitation know that it involves selecting the right mix of team members, designing
the work plan properly (including parceling out assignments and setting ground
rules regarding the way members will interact with each other), holding a
mirror up when the group members are not working well together, mediating among
contending individuals and serving as a scribe so there is a reliable record of
what transpired. While it is possible to
contract out for many of these facilitation services, leaders better understand
exactly what the facilitation assistance is that they want and need. And,
sometimes, only the leader can resolve internal team disagreements.
Negotiating in a
value-creating fashion
The success of many organizations hinges on the ability of
their leaders to negotiate effectively with representatives or leaders of other
organizations. Supply chains work that way, as do inter-organizational
partnerships. Leaders who think that these kinds of negotiations are like
traditional win-lose bartering in the market place, do their organizations a
terrible disservice. Negotiating when long-term relationships are important, requires
a different (i.e., “mutual gains”) approach to deal-making. The Mutual Gains
Approach (MGA) to negotiation requires finding trades or ways of reframing
disagreements that add to, rather than just divide, value. The most successful
leaders know how to do this.
As colleges and universities re-organize to enhance the breadth
of the leadership skills they are imparting, I hope they will realize that the
learning involved is probably not best presented in traditional semester-long
courses, nor delivered in lecture format. Helping students learn from their own
experience, and engage as co-learners with others (often online), will require
new pedagogical strategies. And, when
this happens, learners are likely to demand certification: not just an
indication that they have completed the required work, but a guarantee that
they have achieved mastery of the skills involved.
Posted by Lawrence Susskind at 7:42 AM 0 comments
Labels: breadth of leadership skills, constructive problem-solving, distributed and facilitative leadership, facilitating group efforts, leadership, MIT, pedagogy, value-creeatig negotiation
Sunday, August 13, 2017
Big Data, Urban Science and the Search for New Ways of Improving Life in the City
There are some urban planners and city administrators who
believe that if they had that kind of information they would be able to figure
out when and how to spend public money, allocate equipment and personnel and
restrict and support private efforts most efficiently. They also think they could use the same data
to anticipate certain tipping points so that traffic snarls could be avoided
before they happen, public works staff (including police and fire) could be
deployed where they would be most needed, and infrastructure repairs could be
managed with minimal disruption. With such information, the presumption is, water,
electricity and other city resources could be priced and deployed on a
real-time basis in the most cost-effective way possible. Empty housing and
commercial space could be repurposed almost immediately, and priced to match
the city’s urban development objectives. Taxes and fees could be collected
electronically while feedback from residents could be shared with officials on
a continuous basis. With the right kinds of electronic monitoring (including
sensors of all kinds), sufficient data collection, investment in high-level analytic
capabilities and appropriately trained staff, a city could become a “smart city.” All this digitized data could be displayed in
visual form -- across multiple platforms – so that everything would be easy to
read and understand.
Of course, knowing what problems a city faces, and even understanding
what’s causing them, is not the same thing as being able to respond
effectively. The availability of real time data, even with the most advanced application
of artificial intelligence, won’t make it clear who ought to do what, in what
order, in what way and for whose benefit. These are political choices: “is”
does not lead directly to “ought”
One school of thought, promoted by some economists and
engineers, assumes that the goal of city management should be to maximize
efficiency – eliminate waste and stretch every dollar as far as possible. They want to make sure public that tax
revenue, fees and intergovernmental transfers are allocated in the most cost-effective
fashion. If the goal is to collect trash, arrest criminals, clean-up air and
water pollution, or fight climate change, money shouldn’t be wasted in the
process.
A second school of thought, inspired by ecologists and
advocates of sustainable development, believes that every dollar of public
spending should be used to meet economic, environmental and social needs simultaneously, in ways that takes
account of long-term needs. Efficiency in the short-term isn’t as important to
these thinkers as long-term sustainability (which includes meeting the needs of
both current and future generations in as fair a way as possible). All the data
in the world won’t make it clear what ought to be done. In a democracy, such
choices need to be made through a messy process of reconciling conflicting
interests and values in which the population participates directly. Efficiency
isn’t always the highest priority goal.
My own university, MIT, is thinking about launching a new
undergraduate degree program in Big Data and Urban Science. This would bring
together faculty from urban planning, information science, electrical engineering,
city design and the applied social sciences to prepare undergraduates to build
and operate smart cities. Other universities, as described in a recent issue of
the Chronicle
of Higher Education, are a step ahead. NYU, Northeastern, Carnegie-Mellon, John
Hopkins, University of Illinois, University of Rotterdam and others have
already launched undergraduate and graduate degree programs that seek to merge
teaching about big data and urban studies.
As faculty in all of these programs try to decide what skills
and knowledge they want a new generation of urban scientists to master, there
are six questions I think they need to confront:
1.
What do
we mean by a city? (Are they talking
about activities that take place within a municipal boundary, or will they
focus on a larger set of regional, national and international forces that shape
urban life more generally?)
2.
Do they
think that privacy is a concern? (Do they assume that any and all information
that can be collected, should be collected? And should this information be
available to anybody who wants to use it?
Can people or organizations opt out and keep information about
themselves private?)
3. How will we fend off cyber-attacks on
critical urban infrastructure that have already begun? (If urban science
means greater centralization of information and data management, won’t that
increase vulnerability to attack?)
4.
Who do
they think should be in charge of designing and managing big data systems and
setting the standards used to make judgments about what’s working well and
what’s not? (Will this be a managerial task assigned to various government
agencies, or will elected officials be accountable for how all this information
is collected, analyzed and interpreted?
Will new laws be required to ensure that individual and organizational
rights are protected? Will this require federal, state or local legislation?
Where will enforcement responsibility sit?)
5. Will they be working from and toward an
idealized model of an efficient city, or will they work to preserve historical and
cultural diversity and variation? (I presume that students from all over
the world will want to participate in these programs? Won’t the differences in
culture, laws, and history require very different ways of applying the new
urban science in each country? Should we assume that this is basically a
technical education and teach a kind of “one-world view”? Or, would that be a
terrible mistake?)
6.
Are the
universities involved aiming to prepare public employees (whose job it is to
serve the public interest), or are they
training experts who will sell their services to the highest bidder?
The City As a Place
vs. the City as an Idea
Most efforts to model urban dynamics assume that a city can
be described as a series of “stocks” and “flows” within a set of
boundaries. While there are always
important “feedback loops,” many of which are likely to cause unexpected
consequences, most modeling (and forecasting) efforts begin by postulating a
set of boundaries. But, what if cities,
as many urbanists contend, are largely a
product of a great many extra-territorial (even global) forces? Capital or data
flows originating in other parts of the world may have as much of an effects
as economic and social forces
originating in the city. Moreover, if we say that the operation of many of the
sub-systems in a city reflect the ways that groups of people or institutions
think about things – their perceptions -- how do we include these in the models
we teach students to build? The city is
a physical space affected by global geological and ecological forces. It is
also an idea shaped by millions of individual perceptions. Will it be possible
to make sufficiently simplified models of the city to generate useful insights
and predictions?
What’s Confidential
and What’s Not?
Assume we can answer the first question, and we know which data
are required to make a city substantially smarter. Gathering some of these data will require
tapping into otherwise secure or private data sources. And, even if we argue that individual
identities will be scrubbed, should people and organizations be forced to give
up their privacy in the name of the greater good? In the United States, we are
currently watching a version of this question play out as a National Commission
on Elections and Voting demands that all 50 states to turn over voting data
that may reveal how specific individuals voted. When it comes to financial
records (including tax returns and credit card expenditures), even if these
data are crucial to modelling how a city is doing, should individuals have a
right to keep such personal data confidential? What ethical obligations will we impose ona
new generation of big data analysts or urban scientists?
Cyber-Security in the
Urban Realm
Urban infrastructure is already under attack from hackers
who seek to hold energy, medical, water, sewage and other systems hostage. Each
new layer of encryption added in response just ups the ante. These systems are
vulnerable because individuals are not as conscious of their cyber-security
responsibilities as they should be. Solutions
will require further technological innovation and investment, but that won’t be
sufficient. What will we teach a new
generation about cyber-security and how to maintain it? And, given the vulnerability of critical
urban infrastructure to global attack, should that affect what we guarantee
with regard to privacy and control over personal data?
Knowledge, Power and
Authority
Let’s say a city has put together a comprehensive data
gathering, analysis and visualization operation. Who will have access to the
raw data? Who will have the right to
publish analyses of the information that has been collected? Will the city be willing to share assessments
of things that residents think are going badly?
Will those who want to challenge current office holders be allowed access
and permitted to publish any analysis they like? Who will make decisions about how data should
and should not be interpreted? It’s my assumptions
that managers of smart cities will have “to do” lists that far exceed their
resources. Setting priorities (often in
real time) will require quick decisions, faster than the public can follow. If
all big data about cities were open sourced, would that allow more citizens to
be involved in helping to make decisions that are going to affect them? While real time referenda might be possible,
is that how cities should set priorities and make judgments?
Is There an Ideal
City?
Urban planners are very place-oriented; data scientists are
not. Urban planners want to preserve the
special historical and cultural features of each city. Data scientists, on the other hand, are looking for rules of thumb to describe the
most efficient ways of delivering goods and services in general. They might
inclined to disregard inefficiencies that are a by-product of local history,
culture or values. There’s no point
collecting data if there’s no intention to use it, but putting all these data
to use means measuring how things are going compared to some benchmarks. Should benchmarks be unique to each
community? Or, is the goal of merging
big data and urban science to create “ideal benchmarks” (based on studies of
many cities over time)? Should urban
science be practiced differently in different cities, let alone different
countries?
Public Sector vs.
Private Sector Careers
Urban planning education in North America has been provided
by major colleges and universities for more than 80 years. The majority of graduates of such programs
aspire to work in the public sector or in civil society (e.g. NGOs or public
interest organizations). This is true
regardless of where students originate.
Of course, some graduates find private sector jobs, either temporarily
or permanently in consulting firms or corporations. Whether they are headed to
the public or private sector, students studying urban planning tend to focus on
ways of meeting the needs of the poor and the disadvantaged; they start with a
theory of market failure and look for ways of using public-private
partnerships, regulation, public investment or political advocacy to meet the
needs of those for whom the market tends to fail. The engineers and scientists likely to be
drawn to these new urban science programs may not be so public sector
oriented. Will the new urban
scientists/big data managers who graduate from these programs be public sector/civil
society or private sector oriented?
I see the emergence of interdisciplinary urban science
programs around the world as a good sign. Merging the capabilities of scientists
and engineers with applied social scientists, designers and urbanists
interested in the life of urban residents would be a positive development. We need to provide all the help we can to
people in cities trying to make adjustments and reforms that reflect a
clear-headed awareness of the complex dynamics they face. I worry, though, that
some universities moving in this direction may pay too much attention to the
advice of economists and management gurus obsessed with numerical trends, who
are willing to focus on correlation because they don’t have the tools to
understand causal dynamics. I hope that the applied social scientists and urban
planners will succeed in ensuring that progressive values like concerns about
fairness and sustainability at the core of the training of a new generation of
urban scientists. I’m certainly glad that most of the people involved in these
new efforts appear to be committed to blending schools of thought that have
operated separately for too long.
Posted by Lawrence Susskind at 1:49 PM 0 comments
Labels: big data, cities and cybersecurity, city management, infrastructure, MIT, MIT Department of Urban Studies and Planning, new careers, the city as an idea, the efficient city, Urban science
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)